跳到正文
原文
Adweek· Robert Klara·· 11 天前AI 评分27

2026 美国中期选举最恶劣负面广告效果复盘,四支广告中三支的候选人落败

Did the Sleaziest Political Ads From the 2026 Midterms Work?

文章要点
  • 1Adweek 此前评出 2026 中期选举四支最恶劣负面广告,其中三支背后的候选人落败
  • 2Ramaswamy 借对手母亲之口称其性侵指控说谎,Acton 反以 7.9 的领先幅度当选
  • 3加州共和党候选人 Steve Hilton 用 AI 生成的女孩在卧室性尝试画面拉票,选民并不买账
  • 4剑桥大学 2014 年研究指出,负面广告在实务中很流行,但几乎没有证据表明它们特别有效
决策要点

2026 中期选举的结果给负面攻击广告的有效性泼了冷水,越界的攻击反而拖累了攻击方自身。

  • 影响:攻击性或擦边创意一旦越过受众底线,反噬会落到投放方自己身上,文中四支最恶劣广告有三支的候选人落败;AI 生成争议内容会放大舆论与声誉风险;负面策略的长期有效性本就缺少研究支持。
  • 参考:可考虑把攻击性或擦边创意纳入投放前的高风险评审,先小范围测试受众反应再决定放量;使用 AI 生成人物或敏感画面时,值得先明确内容红线;评估负面竞对打法时,可先复盘失败案例的占比。
  • 依据:Adweek 统计的四支最恶劣广告中三支的候选人落败,Acton 以 7.9 领先当选为选举结果;有效性判断引自剑桥大学 2014 年研究。
正文

Democratic political strategist Dane Strother once observed that “negative ads and campaigns do work—and have for more than 2,000 years.” (Political slams have been unearthed in Pompeii.)

“The day that negative ads no longer are effective,” he added, “they no longer will be used.”

Has that day arrived? Based on the midterm results, it seems closer.

Last week, ADWEEK waded through the muck to pick out the four most egregious ads of the 2026 midterms. Even by the mudslinging standards of American political life, these spots hit below the belt. 

They included Republican Sen. Roger Marshall of Kansas charging that his opponent Adam Hamilton “protected” a child molester, and Ohio Republican gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy’s now infamous ad in which the mother of his opponent Amy Acton—who has said she was sexually abused by her father—calls her a liar.

So, how well did these ads work? Not very. Three of the candidates behind these ads wound up losing their races.

While a man later convicted of misdemeanor sexual battery did work briefly at a summer camp run by pastor Hamilton, Marshall’s equating that to his opponent’s having “protected a pedophile” was apparently too much.

Voters also didn’t much care for California Republican gubernatorial candidate Steve Hilton using AI-generated girls sexually experimenting in a bedroom as a means of encouraging Democrats to vote Republican.

As for Ramaswamy’s ad, Acton told CNN that the ad that questioned her sexual abuse allegations—and used her own mother to do it—“crossed everyone’s boundaries.” Voters clearly agreed, electing her by a 7.9 margin.

From our low-blow list, only Democrat Brian Poindexter won his congressional race in Ohio’s 7th district with the help of an ugly ad that reminded voters that incumbent Republican Max Miller’s wife Emily Moreno has accused him of domestic abuse. (Miller has denied the charges.)

But as NBC affiliate WKYC reported, Poindexter had already been winning supporters by touting his blue-collar background as an ironworker well before the abuse allegations started getting media traction.

The big takeaway from 2026 might actually lay in research published by Cambridge University way back in 2014. Down and dirty ads, it said, “have become so popular in practice,” even though “there is so little evidence that they work especially well.”

来源:Adweek · adweek.com